Continuing down the list…
8. Dressing up/roleplay
This one is actually surprisingly tricky. As Rob Bell was fond of saying in his book ‘Sex God’, “This is about that.” Sexual fantasies, God love them, have a sometimes bafflingly broad spectrum. Any appetite is like to inspire some daydreaming. Sex fantasies are equivalent to food cravings; they often nag until satisfied, they can be a barometer of the health of one’s appetite, and they get weird when pregnant women are involved.
Preggers big-love aside, there is a very important similarity between fantasies and cravings: exposure. No farmer in Germany during the middle ages ever got a craving for raw squid and avocado surrounded by white rice, wrapped in seaweed and topped with wasabi. (Which is delicious, by the way.) Why? Because he had no idea that sushi existed or, more like than not, that any of those ingredients existed. You don’t get hunger cravings for food you don’t know exists. In fact, have you ever gotten a craving for food you’ve never tasted?
Sex fantasies, I believe, work on the same principle: you have to know it’s out there to want it. If that is true, then roleplaying will always be derived from some aspect of your own life experience. Since sex is all about intimacy, the elements of your sexual development should be shared between spouses. If your first crush was a teacher or you got the pretty nurse when you broke your arm in middle school, those would be perfectly healthy fantasies as an adult. If you lack the gift of contenance, the occasional whig, accent or “that’s not me” article of clothing on your spouse may do you quite a lot of good.
However, it is important not to forget yourself in sex. When roleplaying it is possible to become, in many respects, someone else. Sex needs to always be you and your spouse, the more of you there is involved, the better. Also, I think it’s very unwise to pursue a sexual fantasy without knowing where it came from. Some people, in day-to-day life, need a certain amount of risk to be interested and others are terrified of risking anything ever. In both cases, an element of danger from a “getting caught” fantasy to a rape fantasy could aide your intimacy. If you want the danger element because you’re attracted to the idea of “dirty” sex, you should avoid it.
The fantasies that you engage in, should be an expression of self. Either the person you feel you are or the person you want to be. Some fantasies, however, distort what sex ought to be. For instance, while I do not oppose the use of sex toys, I would oppose using them to indulge a gang-bang fantasy. If a woman wants her husband to be rough or to bind her because she wants to feel that he possesses her; that’s wonderful. This is an expression of wanting to feel unconditional belonging and/or a positive reaction to that one part of the Edenic curse. On the other hand, if she wants to be punished because she really wants to do bad things or because she feels she deserves punishment for something she did or a certain way she is; this is a bad sign.
Also, this shouldn’t be taken as an opportunity to play out your lusts for someone other than your spouse. For those lacking sexual continence, or “Akrasians” to borrow from the Greek, the eye does not wander because they are unsatisfied with their spouse in a specific way (i.e. she’s not pretty enough or he doesn’t listen enough) or they think about sex in terms of conquests. Those people are not Akrasian, they are merely dissatisfied or players. If you are truly Akrasian, you don’t think in terms of superiority (“I like her hair better than my wife’s”), you just like variety (“Blond is as nice as brunette is as nice as red hair”); but you may like it enough to cheat. In these cases, as I said before, adopting that variety will be a good thing because these variations have nothing to do with the Selfness of the spouse; the spoon doesn’t change, just the soup.
That whole “same spoon” thing has to stay firmly in your mind when you take on roleplaying. Emphasizing different parts of your personality or exploring the person you’re afraid to be is fine, this is still you and your values. Do not let yourself or your spouse become someone else or entertain the person you’d be if you weren’t a believer.